diff --git a/modules/round/src/main/Rematcher.scala b/modules/round/src/main/Rematcher.scala
index 8adeb06fc5..4168d873e0 100644
--- a/modules/round/src/main/Rematcher.scala
+++ b/modules/round/src/main/Rematcher.scala
@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ private[round] final class Rematcher(
       clock = pov.game.clock map (_.reset)),
     whitePlayer = whitePlayer,
     blackPlayer = blackPlayer,
-    creatorColor = !pov.color,
+    creatorColor = !pov.game.creatorColor,
     mode = pov.game.mode,
     variant = pov.game.variant,
     source = pov.game.source | Source.Lobby,